Nobody Buys Your Book Because You Need Them To | Ally Machate

ADD SCHEMA BELOW -  DELETE THIS MODULE

If you are writing a nonfiction book solely to drive individual book sales on Amazon, you are leaving your business's biggest growth engine on the table.

 

In this episode of The Writing Biz, host Laura Williams sits down with Ally Machate, former Big Five editor, bestselling ghostwriter, and founder of The Writer's Ally. Ally breaks down why treating a book as a business growth lever—rather than a passive royalty generator—changes everything from your developmental outline to your launch strategy.

Q: Why shouldn't business owners focus on book cover price royalties?

A: When you publish a book connected to your business or professional expertise, treating single-copy sales as the ultimate finish line blinds you to the real return on investment.

A self-published book might net you $5 per copy, but selling 100 copies yields just $500. Conversely, giving away 100 copies that ultimately land even two or three high-ticket consulting clients or premium coaching packages will vastly outperform a bestselling title that does nothing for your bottom line. A book is an asset that earns authority, media exposure, speaking engagements, and inbound qualified leads.

"The true value of your book is not in the cover price. It's in what the book can bring to your business. It's a lever, the book. It's not just the finish line." — Ally Machate

Q: What is the "Good Book, Wrong Book" problem?

A: Many authors write manuscripts that are objectively well-written, cleanly formatted, and polished, yet fail to generate reviews, sales, or clients because they lack built-in marketability.

Marketability is inherent to the book's architecture—not tactical post-launch promotion like running ads. When authors try to speak to everyone, cram every ounce of their knowledge into a single draft, or fail to define their reader's specific pain point, the message gets watered down. The manuscript must promise a concrete solution that directly aligns with a defined audience and a specific backend business goal.

Q: Why is writing a broad book a major positioning mistake?

A: Authors often fear that narrowing their focus will limit their potential audience, so they pitch their books as universally useful.

In reality, trying to speak to everyone guarantees connecting with no one. Publishers look for precise positioning: where your book sits on the shelf, which specific query it solves, and how it stands apart from immediate competitors. Today’s discovery algorithms—including AI search, Amazon's search, and search engine optimization—require hyper-specific titles, subtitles, and cover copy to correctly recommend your book when users search for targeted solutions.

Q: How much workshop or service content should you include without "giving away the farm"?

A: A frequent trap for coaches and service providers is holding back valuable solutions out of fear that readers will DIY their problem and never hire them.

This produces a glorified calling card—an empty, repetitive sales pitch disguised as a book that completely destroys reader trust. True ideal clients will never substitute reading a book for hands-on, high-touch implementation with you; instead, experiencing your genuine expertise builds the necessary know, like, and trust factor to make hiring you their logical next step.

"If you don't give some real value, if you don't at least help people to take one true step in the direction they're trying to go, then the book has failed because it hasn't built the like, know, trust factor." — Ally Machate

Q: What are the non-negotiables during book launch week?

A: Your launch is not about selling books; it is about seeding books and driving review momentum.

Amazon's algorithm depends on conversion rates and early positive customer reviews, especially across the initial 30 to 90 days post-launch. Rather than burning ad spend driving cold traffic to an unproven sales page with zero social proof, focus strictly on seeding copies directly into the hands of your target audience and systematically collecting verified reviews.

Stop viewing your publication date as the finish line and start treating it as the opening day of your marketing engine. Align your core promise, clarify your audience, and build your book to work for your business every single day.

Episode Timestamps:

00:00 Introduction to Ally Machate and The Writer's Ally 

00:37 Why Book Royalties Aren't the Ultimate Business Goal 

03:31 Solving the "Good Book, Wrong Book" Dilemma 

09:40 Optimizing Nonfiction Titles, Subtitles, and AI Discovery 

13:37 Positioning Blind Spots and the Danger of Writing for Everyone

17:16 Why Your Book Shouldn't Be a Glorified Calling Card 

24:58 Repurposing Book Content and Launching as a Starting Line

27:28 Launch Week Non-Negotiables and Ads to Skip 

38:02 Balancing Personal Author Platform with Book Hooks 

44:01 The Write Book Method and The Writer's Ally Process

Ally machate, founder of The Writer's Ally profile image

Meet Ally Machate:

Ally Machate is a publishing strategist, author services expert, and founder of The Writer’s Ally. A former Simon & Schuster editor who’s been in the book industry since 1999, she helps authors write, publish, and sell high-quality books that fuel business growth, attract ideal clients, and boost authority. Known for her honest, strategic approach, Ally helps authors cut through the noise, avoid costly mistakes, and turn their books into real engines of visibility and results.

Personal

  • LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

Business

  • Website
  • Facebook
  • YouTube

FREE WEBINAR FOR THE WRITING BIZ AUDIENCE

“Don’t Write the Wrong Book!”

Before you invest time, money, or momentum in a book, make sure you’re writing the right one…the one that will build your business, credibility, and client list.

This free, 25-minute on-demand webinar from The Writer's Ally will help you avoid that.

JOIN THE NEWSLETTER

Get writing business tips, episode updates, and exclusive resources delivered to your inbox.

JOIN THE NEWSLETTER

Get writing business tips, episode updates, and exclusive resources delivered to your inbox.

Tools For Your Writing Biz

💫DIY Book Covers: Book Cover Formatting & Mockups: 

💫Canva: Graphic Design & Photo Editing Software

💫Sign up for GOOGLE WORKSPACE and organize your business in one place.

Get your FREE Website Audit report inside three business days, in plain language, listing what’s working and what isn’t, with separate findings for SEO, GEO, and AEO so you know exactly which one is holding you back, and roughly what each fix would take. No dashboard full of scores you have to interpret. No sales call required to receive it

If the honest answer is that your site is fine and one small change would help, that’s what the report says.

A square promotional announcement featuring a clean split layout. The top two-thirds features a white background headlined at the top left with "NEXT EPISODE 10.16.26" in bold red capital letters. Below it, bold black sans-serif typography reads: "Marcia Layton-Turner shares how can writers transition from chasing low-rate freelance gigs to commanding five- and six-figure fees by positioning themselves as strategic publishing partners for CEOs and entrepreneurs". In the upper right corner sits The Writing Biz Podcast logo, displayed in a bright yellow square badge with bold black and red lettering alongside the tagline "BETTER WRITERS BIGGER OPPORTUNITIES". The lower right features a headshot of Dr. Marcia Layton Turner, a smiling blonde woman wearing a textured yellow top. The bottom section transitions into a black lower third separated by a thin red accent stripe, containing the white text: "DR. MARCIA LAYTON TURNER, AWARD-WINNING BUSINESS GHOSTWRITER".

FULL TRANSCRIPT

Nobody Buys Your Book Because You Need Them To with Ally Machate

Laura Williams: [00:00:00] Joining us today to unpack exactly how to market and publish the right book for your business goals is Ally Machate, founder of The Writer's Ally. Ally is a former Big Five editor, a bestselling ghostwriter, and an absolute powerhouse when it comes to helping writers cut through the noise with practical, honest guidance.

Ally, thank you so much for joining me today.

Ally Machate: [00:00:22] I'm so thrilled to be here, Laura. Thanks for having me.

Laura Williams: [00:00:25] Oh, absolutely. So you often emphasize that for an expert or business-minded author, book goals aren't the ultimate goal. So what is the ultimate goal?

Ally Machate: [00:00:37] Yeah, that's a great question, and it's probably surprising to a lot of people when I say this. Yes, of course — you've invested time, energy, and money, you've written a book, you want to sell books.

But if you have a business, if you've written a book as part of your area of expertise, if it ties into your business growth goals, and you're focused on trying to sell one copy at a time, [00:01:00] you are missing out on the true value of your book. The true value of your book is not in the cover price. It's in what the book can bring to your business.

The book is a lever. It's not just the finish line. It's not just a thing that you want to go out and sell — although, of course, you've written a book, you want to sell books. But when you have a business, the real return is what the book opens up for you. So the ultimate goal is a business growth goal, and specifically what that looks like is gonna vary, of course, from author to author and business to business. That's why it's so important that authors be clear about what that goal is before they get their book across the finish line.

A book can open up so many opportunities. It can establish you as an authority. It can bring you leads. It can get you speaking opportunities. It can bring you into the media, into partnerships. Even a book that sells modestly could land you, say, three high-value clients. That would outperform a book that sells thousands of copies and does nothing for your business.

So the [00:02:00] real goal, the ultimate goal, is not just to sell as many copies as possible, or even necessarily to have a bestseller. It's to write a book that you can pull on — a lever you can pull, a tool you can implement — to sell more of whatever it is you sell in your business and achieve whatever it is you need to achieve as part of those business goals.

Laura Williams: [00:02:21] I just think it's such a great way to build who you are online and offline, and to be able to do the speaking gigs and all the other things you're able to do when you build that kind of authority. I think it's a wonderful tool, and I'm glad you came on today, because I like that you make it clear that the book isn't necessarily something that will bring in income by itself, but having the book will help bring in income.

Ally Machate: [00:02:52] It's a real shift from the way most people think about books and what the purpose of a book is. But here's a real simple example. Think about [00:03:00] when you sell a book that you've self-published. Let's say, in the best-case scenario, you make five bucks on that book.

Would you rather sell 100 copies of that book and make $500, or would you rather give away 100 copies of that book and sell your $5,000 coaching package to a number of people, right?

Laura Williams: [00:03:20] So from a strategic standpoint, how can an author identify that they're writing about the wrong thing in the wrong way?

Ally Machate: [00:03:31] It's really a huge problem, and it's sort of a quiet one that a lot of people don't talk about. Oftentimes I meet authors who have published books, and they're happy with the book. It looks good, it reads well, they're proud of it, but it's just not doing anything for them.

It's not getting reviews, it's not opening doors, it's not selling. It's just kind of sitting there. And the problem is usually something I describe as the "good book, wrong book" problem. What that means is that you can write an objectively good [00:04:00] book, and it still may not be marketable — if it isn't strategically designed and aligned with not only that end goal we just talked about, what you want the book to do for you out in the world, but also your target audience.

Who are the people you need to connect with in order to make that goal happen? And working backwards from that, what is it those people are really looking for in a book? What do they really want to hear from you about your area of expertise? What are they looking for, so that when they type those search terms into Amazon or Google — or AI, these days — it's going to bring up your book as the answer or the solution to their query or their need, right?

If you haven't thought about those things and gotten them into alignment, then that good book — again, objectively well written, fun to read, looks good, you put money into it, it's nice and professional looking — may still be the wrong book, because it's not gonna move the needle in your business.

It's not gonna stand out to the people who really need it. [00:05:00] They're not gonna see clearly that it's for them. The promise isn't gonna be compelling enough for them to choose your book over somebody else's, and you're gonna end up with a really attractive paperweight.

I talk a lot about this "good book, wrong book" problem, and what it is is that many people, when they write a book — especially if they're writing their first or even their second book — are very focused on writing a good book. Of course you want to write a good book. But the trick, or the trap, here is that you can objectively create a good book — something that's well written and easy to read, you've put money and time into getting it formatted nicely, you got a good cover on it, you've published it well.

It is by all objective measures a good book, and it may still be the wrong book. And what makes it the wrong book — the red flag that makes it not the right book — is that it isn't marketable. Now, [00:06:00] marketability is not the same as marketing, right? When most people think of marketing, they think of tactics: running ads, running promos, vending at events.

But marketability is something that's inherent to the book itself. We talked a little bit before about strategically aligning your book. What exactly is the goal for your book out in the world, beyond book sales? What is it you want that book to do for you? If you're not clear about that, that's one red flag, because if you don't know what you want your book to do, it's really hard to design a book that can accomplish that goal.

Working backwards from that: who are the people you need to connect with? Who are the target readers you really need to get this book into the hands of in order for that goal to become a reality? And then, working backwards one more step: what is the promise you can make? What is the thing those people are looking for that's gonna have them pick up your book and think, "Yes, this is the answer to my problem. This is what I've been looking for. This is what I need"?

Those three [00:07:00] things need to be clear from the outset, or at least somewhere before you've published the book. Somewhere in the drafting or revising stage, you need to get those three things into alignment. If you haven't, it's very easy to end up with a book that is objectively good by any measure but is still the wrong book, because it's not going to connect with your target audience.

It's not going to compel them to buy your book and take action — whatever action it is you're leading them to take next. They're not gonna choose you over your competitors. Your book's basically just gonna look really nice in your Zoom background, and it's not going to get you those goals and all those benefits you hear people talking about.

So the red flags are: if you haven't thought through those three things; if your book is trying to speak to everybody; if you haven't gotten narrow — if you've made the mistake of trying to be too broad in order to reach the most people, and you've effectively watered down your message and made it too difficult for your ideal readers to see themselves in the book.

If you've been writing and you [00:08:00] feel like you're trying to cram everything you know about a subject into a book, that's also a sign you haven't gotten really clear about exactly what the book is and exactly who it's for, because you don't have any way to make those discerning choices about what to leave in and what to leave out.

And all of this is really important because, as I said, you can invest a lot of time, energy, and money into publishing a book that is good but is the wrong book. And if it's the wrong book, it's not gonna get you the results you want, and you've effectively just wasted a lot of time and energy.

I think the biggest cost of all is the cost to yourself. So many authors make this exact mistake. They publish the book, and the book doesn't do anything. It doesn't get reviews. It doesn't sell. It doesn't bring opportunities. And they take the wrong message away.

They think, "Well, obviously I suck. Nobody cares what I have to say. I never should've done this," right? And that's the wrong message, because they probably do have a lot of value to give and a lot of wonderful things to say, and the [00:09:00] book may even have a lot of content that's very valuable. They just made a strategic error in how they designed the book.

That's the real problem. And so they give up, right? When they really didn't do anything wrong — they just missed a step.

Laura Williams: [00:09:14] I think too — and tell me if I'm wrong — it would be very advantageous to be incredibly specific about the title. With a nonfiction book, I'm trying to solve a problem.

Ally Machate: [00:09:29] Right.

Laura Williams: [00:09:30] So I would think the title would have to be just as specific. It couldn't be something very nuanced. Am I correct in thinking that?

Ally Machate: [00:09:40] Yeah. Titles for nonfiction books have changed a lot, and actually this is starting to apply more to fiction and memoir as well.

Fantasy fiction's a great example. If you've been paying attention lately, you might have noticed that more new books are being published with a kind of reading line, or even almost [00:10:00] a subtitle, which is not typical for most fiction. At most, you'd see something like the name of the series, right?

So you'd see "Book One of the So-and-So Series," and then you'd have the actual title of the book. What we're starting to see now is things like "a romantasy trilogy" or "a grimdark story" — little reading lines that give us a hint. So in nonfiction, we have to account for this a little bit differently as well.

The title is one piece of it when people are searching. If you're searching for a solution to a certain problem, you've got keywords and phrases. The title is absolutely one piece that can help get somebody to your book. But of course, you also have the subtitle, which is another piece of real estate to work with, and a reading line, which is another piece of real estate to work with.

Last but not least, you have the cover copy itself — the copy that serves on sites like Amazon and Goodreads as your book description, or sometimes they call it a book summary. That copy is also searchable by the [00:11:00] Amazon algorithm and by AI. So yes, absolutely, the title matters, but there are a few other pieces you can play with to make sure your book is more visible when people are looking for things.

And to that point, it's very hard to figure out what keywords or what title to use if you aren't clear on what the book is promising and who it's promising it to.

Laura Williams: [00:11:24] And it's so important to become clear on that, because those ideas will flow into all of your branding. When your website's built and everything, knowing what your keywords are, what you're trying to communicate, and who you're trying to communicate to is incredibly important for any author.

But for nonfiction, it's absolutely imperative that it all fits together, because you want to have a consistent presence online, but you also wanna be found for the questions your industry is asking.

Ally Machate: [00:11:59] Yeah, it's so [00:12:00] true, and it's even more true now than ever because of emerging GEO — AI search.

People used to go into Google and type keywords, a phrase, whatever. They might type it into Amazon and get a book. Now people are going to AI and asking those questions, and AI can't recommend you if it isn't clear on what your book is, if it isn't clear on who your book is for, and if your book isn't in alignment with the other things that you do.

If you've basically just written a book because it's the topic du jour, or it's the thing you were really interested in, but it's not clearly aligned with your business or your area of expertise, AI isn't going to be able to discern that that's what you do, and it won't be able to recommend you when people are querying.

Laura Williams: [00:12:43] Right. I build websites, and I'm actually working on a program to do AI audits for GEO and AEO for websites, to show them where their issues are. I think it's gonna work out really well, because it's definitely a [00:13:00] valid concern. You still wanna have SEO in your website, but you should build toward GEO and AEO so that people can actually find you, because we don't do things the same way we did even a year ago.

Ally Machate: [00:13:15] Yeah, that sounds like a great tool.

Laura Williams: [00:13:17] Well, fingers are crossed. I'm working on it. So, drawing from your background as a former Big Five editor, what are the most common marketing or positioning blind spots that independent authors run into that traditional publishers usually catch?

Ally Machate: [00:13:37] Well, we've already touched on one of them, which is the idea that you're trying to write for everyone, or for too broad a market.

A lot of people don't fully understand this truism about marketing, which is absolutely counterintuitive: when you really wanna market something, you don't go as broad as [00:14:00] possible. In fact, it's the opposite. The narrower you get — the more specific and clear you get about what it is and who it's for — the more easily the book can find its target market and find success.

So a lot of people will approach publishers, and they'll take the stance of, "Oh, my book could be useful for everybody. Everybody would be interested in this. Everybody would benefit from it." And the publisher already knows that if you're trying to speak to everybody, you're gonna connect with nobody. So that's a huge, huge mistake — not getting clear or narrow enough about your target audience.

This is really part of something we call positioning, which is a larger conversation. To use a metaphor, imagine your book on a good old-fashioned bookshelf in a brick-and-mortar bookstore. Where exactly is your book?

What is it between? What are the other books around it? Which shelf is it on, right? So where exactly in the category of books like yours does yours get [00:15:00] positioned? How does yours stand out?

Another mistake a lot of authors make is that they're so focused on writing what they wanna write — what they wanna say, the thing that got them started writing in the first place, the thing they're passionate about — which, again, is very understandable. That's a great way to get started. But they get all the way to the end, and they've been so fixated on writing that book and making it as good as possible that they never really stop to think about the other piece of the equation, which of course is the audience. You can write all about what you wanna say and what you think is important, but nobody buys a book because you think they need to, right?

They buy a book because they want to. There's something they need, and they believe you can give it to them. So trying to bolt your positioning onto the book after the manuscript is done — writing the book first and then trying to figure out, "Okay, where exactly does this fit in the market? What exactly is this promising?" — that's also a really huge mistake. That work has to be done much, much earlier, so [00:16:00] that all of those positioning elements — that marketability we talked about earlier — are actually baked into the draft. That's another really common problem.

And probably the third one, just to build on these, is what I call the Field of Dreams myth, right? The idea that if you just write a great enough book, the rest will fall into place. People will find it. It'll go viral. It'll be a bestseller. That's just absolutely not true. The very best book in the world will be a flop if nobody knows it exists.

Laura Williams: [00:16:30] Well, exactly, because we're being inundated with the number of books being self-published — and that's a good thing. We have so much variety. But at the same time, as an author, you have to really work hard and hit all the places you can to get your work out there and get it seen.

So let me ask you a question, 'cause this drives me crazy — it's a [00:17:00] pet peeve of mine. When I buy a nonfiction book, particularly to solve a problem, and it doesn't solve the problem — the author just kind of wanders around the problem. Do you understand what I mean?

Ally Machate: [00:17:16] So, we don't really know what was in that particular author's head, but what I think the problem often is with books like that is that people got the message about a book being a lever for your business, right? They understood the basic concept of, "This book is supposed to bring me business, so I wanna put my ideas out there. I wanna address this problem in a way that draws people into my business ecosystem, gets them to connect with me, gets them to buy from me," whatever that looks like.

But a book can't just be a really big calling card. We talk about it that way informally, like it's a supercharged calling [00:18:00] card, right? You don't leave behind a business card now; you leave behind a book. But people are too afraid that they're giving away the cow, right? Or giving away the milk for free, however that saying goes.

So they think, "Okay, good, I get that's what the book is supposed to do, but if I tell them everything in the book, they're not gonna hire me. They won't need to work with me." And so they end up writing essentially just a long commercial that doesn't actually deliver any value. That's a mistake, and it's a misinterpretation of the basic concept.

The way you really wanna do it is to talk about the problem, obviously, and talk about how you view the problem, but to offer genuine value to the reader — even if the book is designed to have someone take a next step, which is what we want most of the time when we're writing a book for business growth goals, whether that's to get on your list, sign up for a course, come to a talk, buy more books, whatever that next step is.

We almost always want that baked in. But that doesn't mean you have [00:19:00] to hold back on everything, so that they're effectively just reading pages and pages of pitches and redundancies that never actually get them anywhere. If you don't give some real value — if you don't at least help people take one true step in the direction they're trying to go — then the book has failed, because it hasn't built the know, like, and trust factor.

It hasn't proven that you have a particular worldview the reader's gonna benefit from. You haven't convinced the reader that you're someone they can trust and rely on to solve their problem, and they're just not gonna feel compelled to take that next step.

Laura Williams: [00:19:34] Yeah, I absolutely agree, because I read a lot of books on writing, and so often it's the same information just said in a different way. There are no real new solutions or new ideas.

I had a guest on an early episode, Michael Totten. He wrote Write, Edit, Publish.

Ally Machate: [00:19:54] Mm.

Laura Williams: [00:19:54] Which I absolutely love, because he honestly tells you [00:20:00] how to do it, and it's just very refreshing.

Ally Machate: [00:20:04] Yeah. I remember, even early in my career, I worked with a bunch of authors who happened to be leading weekend retreats and workshops, and obviously the books were meant to lead people to do more of those workshops with them.

Laura Williams: [00:20:23] Right.

Ally Machate: [00:20:23] And they would be afraid, right? Like, "Well, if I put too much of my workshop into the book, then they're not gonna come to the workshop. They won't need to." And I really had to explain to them that that's just not how it works.

It's kind of funny the way people buy books sometimes. Maybe 15 years ago or so, there was a period where people would write blogs, package up their blogs into a book, and sell that. And you'd think, "Well, how could that work?" right? Everything is in the blog. Everything's free. But it did work, because plenty of people valued the convenience of having all that information put together in one book instead of having to hunt and peck through the blog one article at a time to find [00:21:00] it.

The same thing is true for the workshops. I'm not saying the book should be a full transcript of exactly what happens in your workshop, but the idea that you have to hold that stuff back because somebody's gonna read it and then not want to work with you — exactly the opposite is true.

There's always gonna be a percentage of people who are gonna buy the book and call it a day. Those people were never your clients. They were never gonna work with you anyway. So really, that's just broadening your reach. There was nothing for those people before; now that you have a book, you're reaching more people.

The people who are truly your ideal clients aren't gonna read that book and decide, "Oh, I can do this myself." They're gonna read that book and say, "Yes, this sounds amazing. I believe this would work for me. I think this is what I need, and I think you're the person to help me, so let me take that next step to work with you."

Laura Williams: [00:21:49] It really helps to bridge the gap between the two things. And with the example you used of a retreat, [00:22:00] if I read the book and got something out of it, I would want the experience of being there. I'm glad those authors found somebody like you who could explain that to them.

It's a tough business out there, and writing nonfiction isn't as easy as people think it is. To do it correctly and make it a marketable product really takes a lot of work and thought, and really knowing — like you said — what you want to accomplish and who you want to reach. It's a whole different ball of wax than fiction writing.

Ally Machate: [00:22:38] Things are a little bit different based on the type of book you're writing, but a lot of what we're talking about is fundamentally the same for selling any kind of book — or really, selling any kind of anything, right?

In some sense, a book is a product just like any other product. Everything we're talking about here, as far as how to make your book more marketable, even applies to your [00:23:00] business, right? People who are listening have probably heard similar advice about marketing their services or whatever it is they sell.

What exactly does this thing do? Who exactly are you trying to reach with your service or your product? What are you promising them that's different, that's gonna compel them to try you over someone else? These things are really crucial.

I think part of the mistake people make is that they think of nonfiction as information. And thanks to AI in particular — though this was already starting to be true before AI, because of the internet at large — books are no longer most people's go-to for pure information.

There are much easier and faster ways to get answers to informational, factual questions. Nobody picks up encyclopedias anymore. Nobody picks up dictionaries and reference books anymore, right? We can go to the internet. We can go to ChatGPT now. We can do all of these other things that give us information.

So if you're not thinking through these [00:24:00] other aspects we've been talking about — if you're not making sure there's something about your book that's truly distinct, if you're just focused on, "Well, there's this thing I think is important, and I'm gonna sit down and write about it so other people can learn about it" — you've gone through a really nice thought exercise, but you haven't written a commercially viable book.

Laura Williams: [00:24:19] Years ago, the term "blog a book" was coined, where you wrote blog posts and turned each blog post into a chapter, so it was a cohesive series of blog posts. I would think the reverse is true as well. When you're writing the book, you should be thinking about how you can repurpose the content in your book to drive some of your marketing. I'd think that's a big piece of what you can explain to people when you take somebody on as a client — having them understand that it's not a one-off.

Ally Machate: [00:24:58] Yeah. You know, [00:25:00] again, it's one of these weird things people don't really think about unless they've worked on hundreds of projects like I have. People are really focused on writing and publishing a book, and they think of the publication date as the finish line, right? "I'm trying to get the book published and out there."

But in a very real way, the launch date — the publication date of your book — is actually the start, not the finish line. There's so much you can do when you've written the right book, when you've gone through all the thinking and research and work we're talking about here today.

You can end up with something that becomes incredibly powerful for your business in all kinds of ways. And yes, one of those ways is definitely as a kind of touchstone, or even the heartbeat, of your business and your marketing. You can pull sections out of your book for blog posts, social posts, webinars, videos, online courses — almost anything. And that's really one of the great benefits of [00:26:00] self-publishing: you have the right to do anything you like with that content, and no one will tell you no.

Laura Williams: [00:26:07] I wish more authors understood that even as you're writing, you can be building your author platform — using little thoughts you have, questions you have, research you came across, all these different things — as content for marketing purposes, so you build interest to where people are ready to buy your book when you do publish it.

Ally Machate: [00:26:39] That's a very smart strategy, and it just reinforces what we've been saying about being consistent in your messaging and your content, and being really clear about who you're speaking to, what promises you're making, and what your message really is. Having all of that cohesively in a book format at the end [00:27:00] of the day is really valuable. But being able to share it along the way with all the people who are starting to follow you, sign up for your list, and come join you — again, it can look different for everybody — is perhaps the best way to make sure the people in your ecosystem are primed and ready for that book when it comes out.

Laura Williams: [00:27:19] What are the non-negotiable elements an author should focus on during launch week, and what can they safely ignore?

Ally Machate: [00:27:28] Launches can be so incredibly stressful. You spend all this time and energy working on the book. Somewhere along the way — hopefully before you get to the very end — you've started thinking about how you want to launch and market the book, and you've got some of those pieces in place. So knowing what to pay attention to and what you can leave out is a really crucial skill, not just for your own sanity, but also for the sake of your wallet.

When you're thinking about your launch, if you need to start making some choices, these are some of the important things to think about. The first is a mindset shift we've already been [00:28:00] touching on: the purpose of your launch is not to sell books. Not if you have a business, not if you're writing a book as part of your business growth plans.

If you've written a novel, a memoir, or narrative nonfiction, that's a different story. But if you've written a book as part of your business strategy, your launch is not about selling books. Your launch is about a few foundational things. I think of marketing in terms of tiers, right? Some things only work if you do them in a certain order, because there are foundational things that need to happen for the later-tier things to work.

When you first launch a book, you're trying to get out as many books as possible. There are different theories — this isn't a hard-and-fast number — but you'll see some experts in the space talking about seeding books, right? Getting out as many as 1,000 books in a year before the book starts to get traction of its own.

So getting books into hands is one of your [00:29:00] most important goals for launch. That's a non-negotiable. You get it into hands so that a couple of different things happen. On Amazon in particular — which is one of the most important places to center your marketing these days — the algorithm responds to lots of people finding your book page, so that's discoverability; then the number of people who find your book page and convert, meaning people who buy your book or download it for free, depending on what you're doing at that particular time. They both count.

And then the third piece is people who are positively reviewing. Amazon wants to see lots and lots of four- and five-star reviews coming in, especially in the first 30 days after your launch. These days, they're saying the first 90 days of your launch are absolutely crucial for the new A10 algorithm on Amazon.

So the non-negotiables are the things directly tied to generating [00:30:00] that kind of activity. If you're trying to sell one copy of a book at a time, it's going to take you years before you've gotten out enough books to actually move the needle and satisfy that idea of seeding the book.

And it's the same with reviews, right? Very small numbers. People are often surprised that the percentage of readers who post reviews is usually quite small. One of the most generous numbers I've seen assumes 10%. So if you assume 10% of people who read your book will actually bother to write a review, think about how many people you need to get to read your book, right?

It's a lot easier to give those books away, or make them available, to get them out faster and get those reviews quicker than to try to sell one copy at a time. And then there are the further marketing efforts, the later-tier things — since you asked about what to safely skip.

I [00:31:00] generally don't recommend that authors run ads — Amazon ads, Facebook ads, that type of social media–based ad — around launch, unless they already have a lot of books out. It's not usually worth it. The math doesn't usually work. And think about it: if you're running ads to drive people to your page and you don't have any reviews yet, you're gonna lose a lot of that traffic.

It becomes kind of worthless to you, because people aren't going to convert if they don't see reviews on the page. That's just one example of why certain things really need to happen first. So the non-negotiables are anything that gets books into the hands of the right readers, and anything that helps you generate reviews as quickly as possible. Anything that doesn't directly influence those goals is something you can skip or save for later.

Laura Williams: [00:31:50] Do you find sometimes, when a client comes to you, that they're surprised they have to build a writing [00:32:00] business to get these things done? Even if you have a publisher, you need a writing business to hold everything up.

Ally Machate: [00:32:09] Yeah, it absolutely is. People sometimes talk to me and say, "Well, I'd really like to get a deal. I'd rather get an agent and a publisher, because I just don't know anything about marketing a book, I don't have time to learn, and I just don't want to deal with that."

But the truth is, even a publisher is going to expect you to be intimately involved in the marketing process. So if you're out there listening and dreaming about a world in which you get to write the book and then just sit back, you're just dreaming, right? That world just doesn't exist.

Laura Williams: [00:32:41] And not only that — you are the best marketing tool you have.

Ally Machate: [00:32:46] So true.

Laura Williams: [00:32:47] And if you put yourself on the sideline, then you kind of deserve what happens, which is nothing. Even the most famous authors market their books. They [00:33:00] do podcast circuits and interviews and TV shows, whatever they need to do. The complaint used to be that it was so hard to reach people pre-internet. Now it's easier, but you're competing with so much noise that you still have to put that same effort and work into it.

Ally Machate: [00:33:25] That's exactly right, and that's exactly the point. The digital age is both a curse and a blessing. It's given us technologies that make it very accessible and feasible to produce your own book and get it out there, and helping that book find its audience is easier in a way that absolutely was not true even 10 or 20 years ago.

But at the same time, it's easier for everybody else, too. So yes, the noise factor is incredible, and now that people are writing books with AI, it's getting even worse. So these [00:34:00] foundational pieces just continue to matter more and more.

Laura Williams: [00:34:05] The authenticity a live author can create in their book has become more and more valuable as we move forward. And that will help tamp down the AI, because people are gonna start losing traction with AI products. We readers are gonna figure out what's AI and what's not, and then those people are gonna give up doing what they're doing, 'cause they're not getting the traction they need. They're wasting time, so they'll move on to something else. I honestly believe that.

Ally Machate: [00:34:35] Yeah. There's always something, right? That's just the truth. Things always change. But yes, to your point, it's an incredibly important mindset shift, and it can be a hard one.

It can be very discouraging. I've had this conversation hundreds of times in my career, where authors really feel like writing the book was the hard part, and now it's gonna be published and it's over — like that's the last step. But as I said earlier, in a very real [00:35:00] way, publishing your book is the first step.

Sometimes people ask me, "Well, how long does a typical marketing effort last? How long do you market a book?" And I say, "For as long as you care about that book," right? There's no point at which you stop marketing the book. When you stop marketing the book, the book is basically dead.

Of course, if you do everything really right and really well, a book can take on a life of its own. It can continue to sell, get word of mouth, and have a bit of its own momentum. That's definitely the goal and the dream, but a lot of that is luck, and that's not most people's experience.

Laura Williams: [00:35:37] No. And your first book is usually a way to work out your kinks. So you always need to be thinking about the second, third, fourth books. You need to be moving ahead. Even though you're still marketing the first book, you should be working on something else, some other way — and maybe it's not a book.

Maybe it's [00:36:00] developing a retreat or something. You should always be moving forward into other opportunities, not just saying, "I wrote this book, and that's the end," if you're really trying to build a business out of the venture.

Ally Machate: [00:36:15] Absolutely, and that's the real power of the book: it makes all of those other efforts you're using to grow your business, expand your visibility, and attract new clients easier. It makes those efforts more effective.

I had a client recently who published a book, and she told me that over the course of the first few weeks she had a bunch of meetings, and the moment she mentioned her book, she could see the difference, right? She could look around the room and see people's faces change. The way they spoke changed. Their level of interest changed. [00:37:00] They hadn't even read the book, right? It was just because she said, "I just published this book, and here it is," and all of that changed immediately.

Laura Williams: [00:37:09] It's almost like instant trust — that this person knows what they're talking about and you can get valuable information from them.

Let me ask you: how can an author balance marketing their own personal platform and authority versus marketing the specific topic or hook of the book itself? As a web designer, I do a lot of author websites, and I encourage authors to have their website in their name, not in their book's name.

Ally Machate: [00:37:40] Oh, yes.

Laura Williams: [00:37:40] Because if they're gonna continue to build a business, that needs to be under their name. They may do things that are unrelated to their books, so they need that broad umbrella. But how would you answer that? How can an author balance their own personal platform versus [00:38:00] marketing a specific topic?

Ally Machate: [00:38:02] Most of us are working with limited budgets and limited energy, and we have lives. We don't want our business to become our whole life, so finding that balance and figuring out the most effective recipe, so to speak, is really crucial. But one of the important things I wanna say first is that these things aren't in competition — or they shouldn't be, right?

If you've done your job the way we've been talking about, your book should be very clearly and obviously tied into your business, or at least some part of it. There are lots of different strategies here. Just to give an example, let's say you wrote a book specifically to bring new leads into a funnel for a new online course you've created.

In a very real sense, that book is directly tied to that one product, and maybe your business has other courses and other products, right? So perhaps that's an example of when a book isn't necessarily tied to everything. But probably that [00:39:00] one online course the book is tied to isn't in a completely different world from your other online courses or your other services and products, right?

If you've got a successful business, you're probably niched down at least to a certain extent, so the book really should be related to the core of what you do, even if it doesn't directly tie into everything. So the hook — the book itself — is what gets the attention. But the platform you've built matters too, because the platform earns the trust, right?

You lead with the hook, because that's what makes someone stop scrolling. But everything downstream of that — the newsletter, the social presence, the way you show up, your credentials, your testimonials, the network you've built — should all be building you up as the person behind the idea, not just the book behind the idea.

So think of them as a one-two punch. And as far as how to [00:40:00] balance your time and energy, I'll make this really simple, to be honest. If you have no platform yet — if you're so early in your business that you're still figuring all of that out — it's probably too early in your business to be writing a book in the first place.

Laura Williams: [00:40:15] Right. No, I agree with that. You have to be making some kind of effort to gain authority in your field, online and offline, before you make the jump into writing a book. At the same time, if you're putting yourself out there as an expert in building a lawn care business—

Ally Machate: [00:40:40] Mm-hmm.

Laura Williams: [00:40:40] —and you're putting all this content out there about building a lawn care business, and then you write a book on the migratory path of hummingbirds, you can't expect that book to do well with the audience you built.

Ally Machate: [00:40:57] That's right. Exactly right.

Laura Williams: [00:40:58] So if you [00:41:00] wanna reach a broad audience, you have to make sure they get that broad feeling from you. And if you wanna reach a narrower niche audience, you have to make sure they see you that way.

Ally Machate: [00:41:12] Yeah. Absolutely.

Laura Williams: [00:41:13] It is a little intuitive, but it's so complicated for somebody who's never stepped into the world of marketing or social media to understand the dos and don'ts.

Ally Machate: [00:41:27] There's a bit of a myth — some really bad advice, quite frankly — that floats around and gives people the mistaken impression that the book is the thing that gives them authority, or that the book is the thing that helps them build the business.

I've met many of these clients in my time. But it's bad advice, because ultimately you have to have a business or a platform to grow before the book makes sense. The book doesn't create the business. It doesn't create your authority. It amplifies it. It grows it. [00:42:00] It gives it more visibility. That's what's really happening.

When we say a book establishes you as an authority in your field, we're not saying the book is the thing that makes you an authority. You already were an authority. It's just that maybe not enough people knew about it outside your immediate audience. The book gets you known more widely.

But this old idea that you become an expert while you write the book — to be honest, that's BS. It's just absolutely bad advice.

Laura Williams: [00:42:27] Yes, I agree. The book shouldn't be the project; it should be a tool in the project. The project should be larger, and your vision should be larger.

I'd think working in a position like yours, where authors come in with all these different kinds of books at different levels of development, would be very interesting — that it would keep the business fresh, with things different all the time.

Ally Machate: [00:42:52] I find so.

Laura Williams: [00:42:54] That's probably why you keep doing it.

Ally Machate: [00:42:55] It's true. It's always interesting. I'm always meeting people. They're writing [00:43:00] about different things. They're running different businesses. They're trying to accomplish different things. And even though, again, there are some elements that any type of book has in common with any other type of book, or any other type of product, there's enough difference and variety to always keep things interesting.

I think that's why it's so important that people — yes, do your research, yes, learn as much as you can on your own — but when you have important, ambitious goals for your business and your book is a piece of that, it's really important to get some professional help, even if it's just an edit and help publishing the book, a consult, or a book coach. Talking to somebody who can help you parse all of this out and make sure you're writing the right book, and that your investment is going to give you a return, is so important.

Laura Williams: [00:43:52] So tell me what you do at The Writer's Ally. What services do you offer, and how do you help [00:44:00] soon-to-be-published authors?

Ally Machate: [00:44:01] My team and I provide a variety of author services. Fundamentally, we help people who want their book to get results. We do work with select fiction writers and memoirists, but primarily we work with nonfiction authors who are writing a book to grow their business or achieve some kind of business goal.

Almost all of our clients start off not with the question most people ask, which is, "Is my book any good? Is it good enough? Is it worth being published?" Instead, the question we start with is, "What do you want the book to do, and is the book you're thinking of writing — or the book you've already written — the right book for the job?"

Because that, to me, is the most important question. And if the answer is no, or if the answer is "Yes, but," then we know exactly where we need to start, and that's usually with developmental editing. Book development is the core of all of our services, whether you're coming in with an idea you need a little help [00:45:00] outlining and fleshing out, or you already have a draft and need somebody with fresh eyes and the right professional perspective to go in and help you see your blind spots.

Where are the weak points? Where are things going really well? Is this the right book? Is there anything we can do to make it land even more strongly with the people it's geared toward? Is there something we can do to make the promise more compelling? Is it in alignment in all the ways we've been talking about?

Your developmental editor helps you through that part of the process. So we do that — it's really important to our process. We have a four-step process we call The Write Book Method. Guide is the first step: that's asking the question and doing the consultation. The second stage is development.

The third stage is to publish and produce the book. That's the polishing — things like copyediting and writing cover copy, creating the layout and design, the files, all the back-end administrative stuff, cover design, and [00:46:00] so on — everything that turns your files into an actual book that's online or in a bookstore, available for sale.

And then, of course, the final stage we call the grow stage. It's not the finish line when your book is published. There's a whole other stage that happens. Now you have the book, and now you get to use it. How are you gonna leverage that book to grow your business? We have a number of book marketing and launch services, and I also work with authors inside my Author Advantage Mastermind, to help business owners and experts who already have their book really suck every last bit of juice out of it — really make sure that book is working hard for their business, that the tool is getting used and not just gathering dust.

Laura Williams: [00:46:42] That's really good that you do that, because I'd think that after a while you build relationships with conferences, and if you see an author's a good fit, you'll be able to advise them and say, "Look, this would be really good for you. Why don't you try to get in here to speak?" I think having those [00:47:00] types of connections would really help.

Ally Machate: [00:47:03] Yeah. I started doing it a couple of years ago. Throughout my entire career, I've always devoted some amount of time to education. I don't think you can really work with authors without offering a certain amount of education, because publishing is so much of an iceberg industry, right? Everybody sees the top part — pop culture, the media, and so on — and they base all their assumptions on just that tiny piece, when in fact there's so much more going on behind the scenes when it comes to publishing a book and marketing a book.

So I started to realize that everybody out there was telling people they needed books — "You need a book, and you need a book, and I'll help you make a book" — and then everyone has books and no one knows what to do with them. It absolutely breaks my heart that people are putting so much time, energy, and money in. The cost of creating a book goes so far beyond even the tangibles, right? There's everything you have to say no to because you're working on a book, [00:48:00] and it sucks up so much of your life.

And as I mentioned earlier, authors take the wrong message away because they simply didn't know how to leverage their book. They thought they'd just publish it and it would do something magically — it would just happen.

So yeah, I really cherish the opportunity to help people see how much value their books really have, in very concrete, strategic ways.

Laura Williams: [00:48:23] I really like that you do that, because it avoids a lot of trash out there on Amazon and other places, and it really helps to have high-quality content that can actually solve a problem, answer a question, or show you that you're not alone — that somebody else has this issue.

Ally Machate: [00:48:45] Oh, thank you so much. I agree, obviously. The world doesn't need more books. There are lots and lots of books. The world needs better books, and it needs better ways for the readers who need what you have to [00:49:00] say to connect with you and find you. That's really what good marketing is.

Laura Williams: [00:49:04] You said that very well. So tell people how they can find you.

Ally Machate: [00:49:10] Please visit our website at thewritersally.com. We have a ton of free resources in a library for you. If you're ready to speak with somebody, you can fill out the contact form there to get a free book strategy call, to find out if we can help you and if we're a good fit for your project.

If listeners go to offers.thewritersally.com/thewritingbiz, they'll find my evergreen training called Don't Write the Wrong Book. It's 25 minutes, and it covers a lot of what we're talking about here today. It introduces a really simple five-step process you can apply to your draft — or to your idea, if you're just thinking about writing a book — to help you understand whether or not you're headed in the right direction, and how to change course if you're not.

Laura Williams: [00:49:53] That's a wonderful resource that would really get you thinking in the right direction. I really appreciate you [00:50:00] coming on today, Ally, because this has been a wealth of information on something we don't talk about a lot: how to build that authority before and after your nonfiction book is published, and how important it is to, like you said, write the best book you can — one that will actually do what you want it to do, get you the results you want, and help build your business. Thank you so much.

To learn more about the podcast and sign up to be the first to know when new episodes are up, visit thewritingbiz.com. Please like, share, and subscribe, and until next time, take what you've learned and put it to work in your writing biz.

Thanks, Ally.

Ally Machate: [00:50:46] Thank you so much.

A promotional grid collage set against a black background features five published book covers arranged symmetrically around a central cover. In the upper left is the vibrant yellow cover of 8-Second PR: New Public Relations Crash Course (2nd Edition) by Liz H. Kelly, illustrated in comic pop-art style with a smiling woman speaking into multiple microphones. In the upper right, Wrangling the Doubt Monster by Bernstein displays clean white and teal blocks with red and blue lettering under a stylized sun illustration. In the lower left, Me, Myself & Multiple Myeloma by Ray Hartjen shows a man walking forward outdoors with ghosted duplicate figures behind him, subtitled "A Behind-the-Scenes Look for Patients, Caregivers & Allies." In the lower right, Sinner's Secret: Sinners Never Die by Julie Rowe depicts a dark, brooding portrait of a dark-haired man against neon city lights. Overlapping the center of the four corners is Peg, Unhinged: A Novel by Teri M. Brown, rendered with soft teal skies, coastal beach houses, and an illustrated blonde woman in a white cover-up reaching out toward her straw sun hat blowing away in the wind.

Support Our Guests

Buy Their Books

A promotional grid collage set against a solid black background features five published book covers arranged symmetrically around a central cover. In the upper left is the dark sci-fi cover of Dissonance Volume 1: Reality by Aaron Ryan, showing an eerie, shadowy alien figure submerged in misty turquoise light above the tagline "We thought they were angelic messengers. We were wrong." In the upper right, To Conquer Death by Harold Moon features a papyrus scroll background filled with ancient Egyptian hieroglyphics behind a dark, fractured metal ankh. In the lower left, The Darker the Skies by Bryan Prosek displays a swirling celestial vortex of blue cosmic lightning and deep space clouds. In the lower right, How to Avoid Book Publishing Blunders by Dr. Judith Briles, "The Book Shepherd," features clean green and purple color blocks with white serif text beneath a round gold Amazon bestseller seal. Overlapping the center of the four corners is the thriller Rhino Horn Underground by Deven Greene, split between a rugged African savanna scene with a white rhinoceros on top and a dark indoor vault below, featuring a severed rhino horn on a pedestal and a blonde woman in a blazer standing nearby.

Some links in this post may be affiliate links or sponsored placements. Supporting our advertisers helps support The Writing Biz at no additional cost to you.